top of page

One Turkey, 2 People: Let The Challenge Begin

Updated: Nov 18, 2020

This year we ended up with a 9.5 kg (21 lb) turkey! Unfortunately, there's no iconic photo of the whole, finished roasted bird. The giant bird was too big for our roasting pan, so we used an aluminum one from the store - which tore halfway through cooking. We had to race to the store, get another pan, transfer everything, and re-foil. In the end, it turned out great, but by the time our turkey was done we were tired and frustrated and in no mood for food photos or social media.

So here's a very pretty stock photo of roasted turkey instead ;)

Roasted Turkey

We're quite excited to take this challenge on and see how many meals we get out of our giant bird. We managed to strip off close to 5 kg (4.884 kg to be exact - aka 10.7 lbs). We're predicting nine to eleven meals for two people.

When we strip the leftover meat, we then separate it into vacuum-sealed freezer bags. We rifle through recipes and decide in advance what we want to use our turkey for, then freeze the amount of turkey needed for each recipe in a bag labeled with the recipe name.

Then we make turkey broth! Our humongous bird yielded 3.8 liters (16 cups) of delicious broth.

We always reserve 5.5 cups of broth for the next turkey roast in a vacuum-sealed bag: • 4 cups for gravy • .5 cup for stuffing

• 1 cup for the bottom of the next edition's roasting pan

How to Eat LeftOver Roasted Turkey
Meals One and Two!

Meal 1 & 2: Traditional Turkey Dinner.

Our first two dinners are back-to-back nights of traditional turkey dinner, with stuffing and mashed potatoes from our garden, drizzled in giblet gravy. This year we had a lovely harvest slaw on the side!


Meal 3: Mango and Basil Turkey Salad

View recipe For sandwiches we freeze about 185g of meat. This is enough to make two generous sandwiches.

This is a classic in our household. The turkey salad is made with mango and ginger aioli, green onion, and fresh basil.

How to Eat Leftover Turkey
Meal 3: Mango Turkey Salad

Meal 4 "Turkey Taco"

The idea was lovely: turn the stuffing into a "taco shell," layer it with mashed maple butternut squash, crispy shredded Brussels sprouts, top with turkey and gravy. This one ended up being an epic kitchen fail! Our "stuffing taco shell" didn't quite work out. We didn't use enough binder, so it just turned into a . . . what shall we call this? Let's go with stuffing hash! LOL

But we don't waste food, so we ate it anyway! We just layered up stuffing hash, turkey, and gravy with the crispy Brussels sprouts on top. Then enjoyed the butternut squash on the side with some corn. We'll be giving this another try next year!

Leftover Roasted Turkey Recipe
The Reality: delicious food pile


Turkey Meal 5: Classic Turkey Salad Sandwich

After the previous kitchen fail, we decided to go simple. Besides, we needed a quick and easy lunch for work. We shredded some turkey, diced an apple, sliced a celery stick, and mixed it all with mayo. Then added a little salt and pepper, placed it on fresh white bread with some butter lettuce.

Leftover Roasted Turkey Recipes
Simple Turkey Salad Sandwich With Apples

Turkey Meal 6: Diner Style Hot Turkey Sandwiches

One of the reasons we make so much gravy is because we loveeee Hot Turkey Sandwiches. This old-school style meal can still be found at authentic diners. It's a pretty straightforward dish. Pour a puddle of hot gravy onto the plate and place a slice of fresh white bread on top of it (when in Saskatoon we recommend that you get yours at Nutana Bakery, it's perfect for this meal) Then layer re-heated sliced turkey breast and pour more gravy on top of that. This is, obviously, intended to be eaten with a fork and knife. The bread becomes a wonderful delivery device for copious amounts of gravy, turning into a sort of gravy bread pudding.

The trick here is reheating the turkey breast so that it is still moist. We slice the turkey breast and layer it into a ceramic dish. We pour over some of the leftover turkey broth until the meat is covered, then add a dollop of butter. Cover it with aluminum foil, and place it in an 350°F for 30 minutes. Remove the turkey and place it on the bread. Again, in the spirit of eliminating food waste (and outright hedonism) feel free to re-freeze the broth for gravy to pour over mashed potatoes, or add it to a turkey soup. This dish is awesome served with mashed potatoes or fries, and a generous pile of buttered sweet peas.

Leftover Turkey Recipes
Diner Style Hot Turkey Sandwiches

Turkey Meal 7: Braised Cabbage and Turkey Sandwich

This sandwich is one of the reasons we make copious amounts of cranberry sauce to freeze. We use our port-cranberry sauce to braise red cabbage, both for a delicious side and as a sandwich topping. Then reheat some turkey meat (see above: Diner Style Hot Turkey Sandwiches), and layer it on bread with goat cheese and bacon.

Leftover Turkey Roast Recipes
Port-Cranberry Braised Cabbage, Goat Cheese and Turkey Sandwich


Turkey Meal 8, 9 & 10 : Turkey Tetrazzini

It is at this point that we realized our giant turkey would provide much more than 11 meals.

Turkey Tetrazzini is one of those dishes we patiently wait for all year long. This pasta casserole is made with a rich and creamy cheese sauce, mushrooms and peas. It's so outrageously good we struggle not to over-eat, but we do always make a big batch. Over the course of a week we enjoyed one Turkey tetrazzini dinner and two lunches. Like any proper casserole, this actually tastes better the next day.

We didn't take the best photo, mostly because we've been waiting for this all year, and once it was ready, we wanted to eat and not food stage!

Leftover Roast Turkey Recipes
Left: A beautiful photo from On the right: our "hurry up and slap on the feed bag, I'm starving" photo

And now, the "sorry we have no photos for these" section :)

Turkey Meal 11, 12 & 13 : Chinese Turkey Soup

Turkey Meal 14, 15 & 16 : Italian Turkey Soup

Turkey Meal 17: Turkey Wrap With Brie, Cranberry Sauce and Arugula


28 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page